Mother Play review

Mother Play by Paula Vogel is a sprawling drama that follows a mother and her two children across four decades. In Melbourne Theatre Company’s season, directed by Lee Lewis, the story is brought to life with compelling performances and smart design choices. With three actors carrying the full weight of the narrative, the production moves confidently through time while exploring the strains, bonds, and psychological complexities of a family shaped by their era.
 
The Herman family’s evolving relationships are anchored by Sigrid Thornton’s powerful portrayal of matriarch Phyllis. Thornton is magnetic and has a presence that doesn't even need dialogue to make an impression. In a delicately constructed wordless montage of time passing, Lewis presents Phyllis alone in her home, where Thornton skilfully communicates the gradual softening of her character’s defences, from the way she carries herself, how she eats and drinks, and even how she observes her surroundings. Every one of her actions are charged with significance.
 
Yael Stone and Ash Flanders play Phyllis’ children, Martha and Carl. Ordinarily, it would be a stretch to accept actors in their 40s playing teenagers, but both Stone and Flanders bring a convincing, wide-eyed energy to their early scenes. They display their characters’ development with restrained voice, stance, and depth. The connection between Martha and Carl is heartfelt with an evident closeness and appreciation that underlines their relationship as it evolves.